Relying on which lawyer you ask, it is perhaps completely authorized or against the law to function a Bitcoin Lightning node. However this space of the legislation has nothing to do with securities or the SEC. Moderately, Bitcoin’s Lightning Community could also be topic to 18 U.S. Code § 1960, the Prohibition of Unlicensed Cash Transmitting Companies.
Bitcoin is a commodity, so operators of normal Bitcoin nodes — which don’t earn charges for validating transactions — aren’t topic to the jurisdiction of the US Securities and Change Fee (SEC).
As an alternative, the US Commodity Futures Trading Fee (CFTC) oversees any buying and selling of Bitcoin futures or derivatives. Positive, the SEC regulates any securitized merchandise involving bitcoin, corresponding to mining corporations and ETFs, however in any other case leaves the community alone.
In distinction to Bitcoin nodes, nonetheless, the Lightning Community makes use of completely totally different software program. Importantly, most Lightning node operators earn charges for routing transactions. This makes their labor fairly distinct from the voluntary, unpaid labor of normal Bitcoin nodes.
For context, the Lightning Community is a mesh community of customers sending and receiving bitcoin off-blockchain through ‘bar tab’-like cost channels. With only one opening and shutting transaction on Bitcoin’s common blockchain, Lightning community customers can route limitless bitcoin by way of Lightning nodes inside seconds and for minimal price. Lightning sacrifices Bitcoin’s absolute safety and decentralization for a budget, quick comfort for this expertise.
The crime of unlicensed cash transmission
Based on US legislation, it’s against the law punishable by up to 5 years in jail to knowingly management or handle an unlicensed cash transmitting enterprise. A cash transmitting enterprise ‘affects interstate or foreign commerce… by transferring funds on behalf of the public by any and all means.’
This contains any one who, with no license, ‘engages as a business in the transmission of currency, funds, or value that substitutes for currency, including any person who engages as a business in an informal money transfer system or any network of people who engage as a business in facilitating the transfer of money domestically or internationally outside of the conventional financial institutions system.’
There are just a few key phrases in that definition, corresponding to ‘business’ and ‘on behalf of the public.’ Nevertheless, the ultimate sentence is frighteningly clear.
For Bitcoin Lightning node operators, nonetheless, it’s not an ideal definition.
Lightning node operators seemingly have interaction with each other as a enterprise. Legally outlined, a enterprise is ‘an enterprise that is carried on for profit or financial gain.’ Lightning routing node operators join to at least one one other in an effort to facilitate the motion of bitcoin for a payment.
In addition they seemingly switch cash ‘outside of the conventional financial institutions system.’
So, are Lightning node operators unlawful cash transmitters? Is working a routing node a federal crime?
Disagreement on whether or not Lightning nodes are unlawful
Nicely, legal professionals disagree on a few phrases right here. Particularly, most legal professionals disagree on the authorized intent of ‘business’ and ‘money.’
It’s unclear whether or not Lightning node operators, even when coordinating with each other to profitably route funds, are meaningfully a ‘business’ as Congress supposed.
Equally, it’s unclear whether or not Congress supposed ‘money’ to embody bitcoin, which possesses some traits of cash — retailer of worth, medium of trade, customary of worth, unit of account, and many others. — however has extra historic volatility than most standard currencies.
One other necessary phrase is ‘on behalf of the public.’ Is the Lightning community actually a public service, or extra a distinct segment for fans?
Learn extra: LND Onion Bomb: One other Lightning Community bug put customers’ bitcoin in danger
Should cash transmitters management funds?
Lastly, many legal professionals disagree on a contentious high quality of cash transmission: management of funds. Based on many pro-crypto legal professionals and even a few senators, cash transmitters should have management of funds in an effort to have interaction within the enterprise of transmitting funds on behalf of the general public.
If true, this might in all probability exempt Lightning routing nodes from the licensing necessities of cash transmission, as Lightning nodes by no means possess nor management bitcoin (besides the one-way management to route a cost alongside a user-specified path).
Nevertheless, the US Justice Division (DoJ) wholeheartedly disagrees that the legislation requires cash transmitters to manage funds. In a courtroom submitting, the DoJ defined its view: “That ‘control’ is a prerequisite for any money transmitting business is legally baseless, contrary to the plain text of the statute.”
The DoJ continued, “Under the ordinary meaning of the word ‘transfer,’ there is no requirement that the transferer exercise control over the funds being transferred… If Congress had intended that control of the funds was a requirement, it could have said as much in the plain text of the statute. It did not.”
Disagreement between pro-crypto legal professionals and the DoJ on the management of funds facet of cash transmission continues immediately. The DoJ is actively litigating felony counts in opposition to defendants just like the Twister Money and Samourai co-founders that rely on Congress not intending to incorporate management of funds in cash transmission statutes. The end result of this disagreement will definitely be fascinating.
No authorized readability for Bitcoin’s Lightning Community
In any case, it’s unlucky for followers of Bitcoin’s Lightning Community that customers don’t have authorized readability. Ask a dozen legal professionals whether or not a Lightning routing node operator is a member of an unlawful cash transmitting enterprise, and you’ll obtain a dozen nuanced responses, sometimes in opposition to different counsel.
In contrast to Bitcoin’s commodity blockchain and community of volunteer nodes, the Lightning Community’s fee-earning routers might need a distinct authorized classification.
Bought a tip? Ship us an e-mail or ProtonMail. For extra knowledgeable information, observe us on X, Instagram, Bluesky, and Google Information, or subscribe to our YouTube channel.